SAP Knowledge Base Article - Public

3842438 - Comments added to widgets are displayed across all filter selections in stories in SAP Analytics Cloud (SAC)

Symptom

  • A user selects a filter value in a story and adds a comment directly to a widget (for example: a chart).
  • After changing the filter selection, the previously added comment remains visible.
  • Users expect comments to be filter-specific and only appear when the same filter value is selected.

Environment

SAP Analytics Cloud 2026.15.16 

Reproducing the Issue

  1. Login to the SAC tenant.
  2. Create new story and add a table or chart widget to the story.
  3. Add story filter with member selections.
  4. Open a story in View mode.
  5. Select filter value "A" in story filter and apply selection.
  6. Add a comment to a table or chart widget by clicking on three dots ->More Options ->Add -> comment.
  7. Enter the comment and then click on Add Comment.
  8. Change the filter value to "B" in story filter and apply selections.
  9. Observe that the comment created for filter value "A" is still displayed when value selected in filter is "B".
    Notice that the previously created widget comment remains visible regardless of the current filter value choice.

Cause

Comments added directly to story widgets(example charts) are stored as story generic comments and do not include the filter context of the selected story filters. Therefore, the system displays these comments regardless of subsequent filter selections.
As a result, comments added to widgets are not filter-dependent and remain visible when users switch between filter values.

Resolution

  1. If filter-dependent commenting is required, use a "Comment Widget" instead of adding comments directly to charts, tables, or other story widgets. Comments created through a Comment Widget include the current filter context and therefore comments are associated with the selected filter context.
  2. Add comment widget [Insert > Add > Others > Comments] in the story, for values to be displayed based on filters.

See Also

Keywords

SAC, comment, filters, story , KBA , LOD-ANA-CMT , SAC collaboration, commenting , Problem

Product

SAP Analytics Cloud 1.0